All Member Open Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-25-2023 05:46 PM

    Looking for information on how to calculate the number of maintenance techs needed to support a Stamping Plant.



    ------------------------------
    Michael Stack
    Senior Maintenance Engineer
    Nissan North America
    Madison MS
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-28-2023 07:57 AM

    Hi Michael,

    The question you ask has specific methods to calculate how many of which craft one needs to support the plant. What I describe here may generate a lot of questions, so I am open to a Teams or Zoom discussion. This is the core of how I've been successful helping maintenance organizations right-size for over 20 major corporations.

    Assuming that you are estimating the manhours required during job planning and measuring how close you come to those estimates during KPI review, there are two elements.

    The first element looks at the known, predictable components of maintenance: PM's and PdM's. Level load the PM and PdM manhours by craft on an annual schedule to eliminate as much peaking as possible. This creates a base for weekly measurement and monitoring of workloads.

    The next element comes from Terry Wireman, World Class Maintenance Management. It is Weeks of Work, with a lot of refinements since he published his book. Measuring current backlogs of both proactive and reactive work, it's accuracy is dependent on how well defined (and followed) your work prioritization and definition of job ready for execution is. Namely a job is not "ready for execution" (not placed on schedules to be handed to the crews) until it is due, and materials are known available.

    Weeks of Work measures how many weeks of work are in the scheduler's four week, rolling schedule that will generate to the current week for crews to execute. The measure reports how many weeks of work are in the four-week schedule for each crew.  If the measure is one week of work for a crew, that crew will run out of work without intervention. If it measures six weeks of work, that crew cannot complete all the work unless they get help.

    There is a Weeks of Work worksheet. An Excel spreadsheet for each crew, it allows for emergent and break-in work, performance to estimates, vacations and absenteeism. It can be used for the short-term, moving manpower to the work or calling for contractors. It can also be used for long-term, creating the basis for plant headcount by craft.

    As I said, there is more to this than can be intelligibly described in an email. Let me know if you'd like to chat.



    ------------------------------
    Mike Palm
    Managing Partner
    Convergent Results
    Cockeysville MD
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-28-2023 08:44 AM

    Sounds like Mike Palm has good information on a detailed analysis. At a very high level, during our last assessment, we looked at the SMRP Benchmark KPI for RAV (replacement asset value) / Craft-wage headcount. There was a suggested best in class of 8-10M for chemical plant of our size. As a high level benchmark the value has some weaknesses. Different industry can't necessarily be compared directly (I have no experience with stamping plant). The maturity of your maintenance and reliability program can have a big effect on needed resources. Heavily reactive work practices will not reach best practice in this benchmark. An accurate/comparable value for RAV was a little difficult for me to obtain. I believe this KPI was useful, along with the other KPI, to help management understand where we are within our industry and the quality of our site program.



    ------------------------------
    Jesse Day
    Sr. Reliability Engineer
    Wacker Polysilicon
    Charleston TN
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-28-2023 11:33 AM

    Jesse how is the RAV calculated. Thanks



    ------------------------------
    Michael Stack
    Senior Maintenance Engineer
    Nissan North America
    Madison MS
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-28-2023 12:55 PM

    SMRP has guidelines. See attached.

     

    Regards,

     

    Mike Palm, PMP, CCMP, CMRP, CSSBB

    (443) 465-1224

     






  • 6.  RE: How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-29-2023 07:57 AM

    We followed the guidelines from SMRP. I worked with the plant comptroller to come up with a number. The site is a fairly new greenfield site so we had something to work with in our systems. 



    ------------------------------
    Jesse Day
    Sr. Reliability Engineer
    Wacker Polysilicon
    Charleston TN
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: How to calculate number of maintenance technicians needed to support a plant

    Posted 08-29-2023 07:50 PM

    If you already have data, use it to set your first benchmarks; the data will need to have a few things available and can be as rough or refined as you have to work with (napkin notes to CMMS). Use info from preventive maintenance plans, breakdowns, required-regulatory tasks, improvement/ construction activities, and any reliability program needs. 

    Use the most knowledgeable techs and leaders to estimate or use actual hours and tech count needed per task to generate hours needed. 
    Now take those hours and don't forget to subtract non-wrench time per day/ then transfer to month/ then year because that is time that can't be used to complete actual work. 
    This will give at least a starting point; as much as I wish a company would use SMRP metrics to staff, the numbers are typically out of budgetary reason (there will be some examples of highly performing companies that may) but good luck finding them. 



    ------------------------------
    Todd Helmintoller
    Cedar Hill TN
    ------------------------------