All Member Open Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  Which Brand PLC is Advisable for FMCG/Chocolate Machinery?

    Posted 06-12-2023 04:34 AM
    I am looking for expertise advise on to choose plc brand for chocolate line machinries. I have option of Allen bradly or siemens.


  • 2.  RE: Which Brand PLC is Advisable for FMCG/Chocolate Machinery?

    Posted 06-13-2023 08:09 AM

    That is a good question. The main thing to consider is the location of the machinery and what brand is most widely adopted in its location. For instance, if the machines are going to be primarily in the North American market, I would suggest Allen-Bradley as it is the most widely supported. For the European markets you should choose Siemens. Both brands create reliable products, but the current global conditions are making it difficult to obtain replacement parts. I would suggest shopping around considering a few key points.

    1. Are components readily available if they were to fail?
    2. Are any of the components selected planned for obsolescence in the near future?
    3. Do they have sufficient aftermarket support? (Think 3rd party parts and service support, in case you are unable to help.)

    These are what I consider when working on any integration. Good luck in your research, and with your automated chocolate lines.



    ------------------------------
    Clayton Robbins, CMRP
    IMR Corporation
    Roswell GA
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Which Brand PLC is Advisable for FMCG/Chocolate Machinery?

    Posted 06-13-2023 09:11 AM
    Dear Mr. Clayton
    Thanks for your reply and key points.

    ---------------------------------
    Vignesh Jeyaseelan
    PLANT MAINTENANCE ENGINER
    Maico Gulf llc
    Ras Al Khaimah
    ---------------------------------





  • 4.  RE: Which Brand PLC is Advisable for FMCG/Chocolate Machinery?

    Posted 06-30-2023 09:40 AM

    Totally agree with this.  Being in North America I tend to use Allen Bradley.  However, the SKF standard is Siemens.



    ------------------------------
    Gerald Sapp II
    Reliability Engineer
    SKF USA Inc.
    West Valley City UT
    ------------------------------