All Member Open Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  CMMS/EAM/ERP

    Posted 13 days ago
    Good morning colleagues,

    I would like to take a quick survey here.  My company (the accounting team) is looking to migrate to an ERP.  We are currently using Maximo but only for maintenance purposes.  I am curious to know what system you use and what the pros and cons are.  My company is looking to move to Microsoft Dynamics F&O.  From what I have researched and after having a meeting with the F&O implementation company I do not believe this is the right move from an asset management, work management, and reliability platform.  Looking forward to hearing from you.  Have a safe day!

    Best Regards,

     

     

    Jason Resler, CMRP, MLT 1, | Reliability Manager 
    Green Plains Inc.,

    Cell:  218-770-3719

    Email: Jason.resler@gpreinc.com

    www.gpreinc.com 

     

    Follow Green Plains: LinkedIn | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

     

    CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: The information contained in this email, including any attachments, is confidential 

    information and is intended only for use by those to whom it is addressed and may be privileged or otherwise 

    protected.  If you are not the intended recipient, any disclosure, copying, printing, or use of this information is 

    prohibited. If you received this information in error, please notify Green Plains via email at info@gpreinc.com

      

    ENTITY NOTICE: Green Plains Inc. owns its assets and operates its businesses through various subsidiaries and 

    also seconds its employees to the general partner of its affiliated public company, Green Plains Partners LP. As 

    such, neither the domain name, the signature block, or any other entity reference in this email shall imply such 

    the employee is working for the entity so identified. Rather, the actions, authorizations, or statements made in any 

    such email shall relate to the applicable Green Plains entity that is the subject of the contract or other legal 

    document to which the topic relates.


  • 2.  RE: CMMS/EAM/ERP

    Posted 12 days ago

    Hi Jason,   this is a good question that I often wonder myself.   Our company with the 140 sites around the world uses several different platforms.  The company has decided to standardize on Maximo but with that said, moving to that platform can be time consuming and difficult.  Pro's Maximo is taking the steps with MAS to move to a reliability platform incorporating Asset Life Cycle management into it.   I will say with some of the improvements,  I don't believe they are fully mature so keeping up with updates is crucial.  Our maximo platform is integrated into SAP which is our ERP system.   This seems to work very well with tracking costs and spend.   Prior to working here,  I've worked a two other companies in my career who also standardized on Maximo so from my perspective it tends to be widely used.   Another Fortune 500 company in the food and beverage used SAP.   SAP gives better reporting but is much more complicated to use for the end user.   Because that was also our ERP system integration was seamless.   Some of the things I see in MAS is they seemed they were in a rush to get to market and are now developing aftwards.  For instance the Maximo Monitor module is not integrated in the Manage module which in my opinion makes it near worthless as we currently use Aveva OSI Pi for monitoring and it's much more powerful.   I do believe with the right staffing and customization you can get Maximo MAS to be a premier platform but it won't be out fo the box.   The other comment that I will make is no matter what platform you decide to go with,  take the time up front to clean up your data before moving it to a new system.  I find over the years and many different companies,  the companies who established their standards up front had the best and easiest to use systems.  Make sure your reliability team has a seat at the table with the IT team when they implement the project to ensure they are looking at it from a maintenance and reliability perspective.    In many cases it has  nothing to do with the platform but a standard organization that could be used between plants and production lines.   This will become imperative as you move toward prescriptive analytics using forms of AI.   



    ------------------------------
    Mark Pospisil
    Program Manager Maintenance Excellence AN Division
    Abbott Laboratories
    Sunbury OH
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: CMMS/EAM/ERP

    Posted 12 days ago

    Good morning, Mark. I appreciate your response.  It's interesting to know that within MAS the Monitor and Manage module are not integrated.  It's also interesting to know that you are using Aveva OSI Pi for monitoring.  We also use Aveva OSI PI, I don't believe we currently use it for monitoring as much as we use it for trending.  I would like to learn more about how you are using it for monitoring.  

    The conundrum I'm having is accounting wants an ERP, I understand that and the reason why.  The issue is Accounting does not understand the full gambit of asset management; hence "any" platform should do the job for tacking PO's and Inventory.  After having meetings with the F&O team, seeing demonstrations, and speaking with others who have used F&O and migrated away for various reasons I simply do not believe this is the right platform for us, especially knowing the accounting only wants the ERP for ease of tracking financial transactions.  To me the right thing is to continue with Maximo and integrate with F&O for the financials.

    I have to say I completely agree with your statement regarding the data cleanse.  That has been an ongoing project of mine for several years now as the original person in charge of the migration from Mapcon to Maximo, there was no cleansing/standardizing of the data before the move.  Job security, I guess.  Thank you for your response and have a safe day!



    ------------------------------
    Jason Resler, CMRP, MLT 1
    Corporate Reliability Manager
    Green Plains Inc.
    Omaha, NE
    jason.resler@gpreinc.com
    218-770-3719
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: CMMS/EAM/ERP

    Posted 11 days ago
    Jason, I’m helping 2 clients with moving away from D365 for CMMS. Would be happy to help guide a bit.

    I’ve been implementing CMMS for 7 years, and currently work for TRACTIAN.

    910-617-3431

    Call or text any time.

    Spencer Pope

    Sent from my iPhone