All Member Open Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  Cmrp Question??

    Posted 05-31-2023 04:57 PM
      |   view attached
    What the correct answer?


  • 2.  RE: Cmrp Question??

    Posted 06-01-2023 07:56 AM

    Hi everybody,

    The Real CMRP exam screen is different from this screenshot so i think it is from a simulation exam or something like this.

    However, EOQ stands for Economic Order Quantity and it is mainly used to order the best quantity from the economic point of view to optimize ordering cost and holding cost. Inventory turn over is related to how many times you emptying and refill you inventory which related to how many parts are ordered each time and for how long they cover your demand. so, from one point EOQ can enhance the turn over (high is good) if you used to order larger quantities than EOQ and it will worthen it if you used to order less quantities of EOQ.

    Generally, I think the correct answer will be true.



    ------------------------------
    Ahmed Mohamed Helmy Khattab
    Almanzala
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Cmrp Question??

    Posted 06-02-2023 08:48 AM

    Ahmed, with respect, not sure your definition of inventory turns is accurate.  Inventory turn is not how many times you turn an individual item over but rather how many times you turn the VALUE of your total inventory not specific materials. calculation for inventory turns in cost of materials issued for the month / the average month ending inventory x 100.

    The reason I discourage anyone from using EOQ is for several reasons. (1) Can anyone tell me what is the exact annual usage for a MRO item? Other than PM materials this is very difficult to be absolute sure what your "Known Usage will be for the year. (2) Can anyone tell exactly what the cost is to place an order? (3) Can anyone tell me exactly what's the percentage for calculating Carrying Cost? How about lead-time which today, is very unstable.



    ------------------------------
    Andrew Gager CAMA, CMRP, CPIM, CRL, CSSGB
    CEO / President
    Wake Forest NC
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Cmrp Question??

    Posted 06-02-2023 11:26 AM

    Hi Andrew,

    I am agreeing with you about turn over definition, and I am also agreeing with your concerns about its usage. 



    ------------------------------
    Ahmed Mohamed Helmy Khattab
    Almanzala
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Cmrp Question??

    Posted 06-05-2023 07:27 AM
    Hi Andrew

    I couldn’t agree with you more, with the current manufacturing restrictions in terms of lead time, material availability, and manpower reduction after the pandemic.
    I believe MOQ formula can be only valid for academic purposes max. Now most of the Enterprises is tailoring their own best of practice to refuel the inventory with the required items.
    We as CMRPs this is will be our goal to exchange data in order to agree upon few formulae compatible with each industry, in the presence of reliable and standard suppliers.

    Thanks

    Sent from my iPhone




  • 6.  RE: Cmrp Question??

    Posted 06-01-2023 08:36 AM
    Edited by David Ghavban 06-02-2023 08:07 AM

    The answer here should be the first option also I will recommend you get this book below as it will help you in preparing for this certification.

    Furthermore,

    Leading indicators are used to predict changes or trends, as well as forward-looking, and help to manage the performance of a system or process.

    Lagging indicator measure performance after the business or process follows a pattern or trend and is used to confirm long-term trends.

    A leading indicator looks forward to future outcomes and events. A lagging indicator looks back at whether the intended result was achieved.

    Maintenance and Reliability Best Practices

    Maintenance and Reliability Best Practices ; Authors, Ramesh Gulati, Ricky Smith

    ; Authors, Ramesh Gulati, Ricky Smith 



    ------------------------------
    DAVID GHAVBAN
    Moncton NB
    ------------------------------